On this page
“Tricep extension” is a family name; “skull crusher” usually describes a lying triceps extension. The useful comparison is therefore lying versus overhead shoulder position, not two completely unrelated muscles or a guaranteed long-head winner.
Short answer: use skull crushers when you want to load heavily and keep the body stable, use an overhead extension when you want a deeper long-head stretch or have only a cable or one dumbbell, and expect a lot of overlap between them.
Terminology tree
- Triceps extension: elbow straightening against resistance; the upper arm may be at the side, overhead, or angled behind the body.[1]
- Skull crusher: commonly a lying barbell, EZ-bar, or dumbbell extension where the elbows bend as the weight travels toward the forehead or behind the head.[1]
- Behind-the-head skull crusher: the same lying lift, but the weight lowers past the head so the upper arm tilts back. An incline bench does something similar.
- Overhead extension: an extension performed with the upper arm beside or behind the head, using a dumbbell, cable, or band.[1]
See the skull crusher and overhead tricep extension pages for technique. The tricep exercises hub covers the wider selection.
Biomechanical Comparison: Lying vs Overhead Extensions
| Feature | Lying Skull Crusher | Overhead Triceps Extension |
|---|---|---|
| Shoulder Position | Shoulder flexed to about 90° (arm perpendicular or angled back) | Shoulder flexed far overhead, often 160° to 180° |
| Long Head Length | Moderately lengthened, more so behind the head | Most lengthened at the bottom |
| Hardest Point | Mid-range, where the forearm is near parallel to the floor | Deep stretched range at the bottom |
| Stability | Bench supports the back, so heavier loads are easier to hold | Standing or seated, so core and shoulder control matter more |
| Equipment | EZ-curl bar, straight barbell, dumbbells, flat or incline bench | Dumbbells, cable with rope, resistance bands |
| Typical Rep Range | 6 to 10 reps | 10 to 15 reps |
The long head crosses both the scapula and the elbow joint, which is why shoulder position changes how stretched it is when the rep begins.1 That is the anatomical basis for choosing overhead work for the long head. How much extra growth the stretch produces over a lying version is the part this page does not claim to know.
Lying skull crushers are stable on the bench, so you can usually handle more absolute load and overload the whole triceps through the middle of the range.
Does a Behind-the-Head Skull Crusher Count as Overhead?
This is the question forum threads keep returning to, and the answer is somewhere in between. Lowering the bar behind the head, or lying on an inclined bench, tilts the upper arm back and lengthens the long head more than a classic skull crusher that lowers toward the forehead. It is still a lying lift with bench support, so it loads heavier than a cable or dumbbell overhead extension.
If you want long-head work but find a full overhead position awkward, a behind-the-head or incline skull crusher is a sensible middle option. If you want the biggest stretch, the overhead version is still the position with the most shoulder flexion. Our triceps long head guide goes further on that muscle.
Which to Choose
- Heavier progressive loading: skull crushers. The bench lets you add weight in small steps and stay stable.
- Long-head emphasis: overhead extensions, with behind-the-head skull crushers as a lying alternative.
- Home or one-dumbbell training: overhead extension with a single dumbbell held in both hands.
- Cable gym: a rope overhead extension, with the pulley set low behind you, keeps tension through the stretch.
- Limited time: pick one and do it well. The two overlap enough that doing both rarely adds as much as an extra set of the one you chose.
On a barbell push day, a lying extension can be a compact accessory after the main press. On a home or cable day, an overhead extension may be easier to scale with one dumbbell or a cable attachment. If your triceps are already tired from close-grip pressing and dips, use fewer direct sets rather than treating a new angle as free volume. Keep the shoulder position that lets you control the bottom and return the weight without a rushed escape. See push day workout for how isolation work sits after the main press.
Shoulder and Elbow Comfort
Neither lift is a guaranteed safe option, and this page has no source comparing injury rates between them. What you can reasonably expect is that the demand moves around. Overhead extensions need comfortable shoulder range, and people who feel pinching at the top often do better with a lower pulley angle, a lighter load, or a lying version. Heavy skull crushers concentrate the work at the elbow, so a lighter load, an EZ bar, or a cable variation is a common adjustment if the elbows complain.
Keep the elbows pointing the same direction through the set. If an exercise causes sharp pain in either joint, stop it and get individual assessment instead of pushing through. Our skull crusher alternatives and bench press elbow flare guide cover swaps and pressing setup.
Programming Both
Do you need both? Not strictly, but a pair works well when they play different roles.
- Put the heavier lift first. Skull crushers or close-grip pressing early in the session, in the 6 to 10 rep range.
- Put the stretch lift later. Overhead extensions after that, in the 10 to 15 rep range, with a slow lowering phase and a short pause at the bottom.
- Count the sets. Volume from pressing, dips, and pushdowns counts toward your weekly training volume as well, so a few hard sets of each extension is usually enough alongside pressing.
- Progress one thing at a time. Add reps until the top of the range, then add weight.
Two sample arrangements:
- Push session A (heavy): Close-Grip Bench Press 3 sets of 6 to 8, then lying EZ-bar skull crusher 3 sets of 8 to 10.
- Push session B (lighter): Cable overhead rope extension 3 sets of 10 to 12 with a 2-second pause, then Tricep Pushdown 2 sets of 12 to 15.
These are starting points, not research-derived prescriptions. Adjust them to recovery and how your arms feel the next day.
Summary & Alternative Substitutes
If you need equipment-specific replacements for cable pushdowns, review our guide to tricep pushdown alternatives.
To program triceps development within a broader split, explore our arm day workout or generate an adaptive program with Your PT’s free plan generator.
Footnotes
-
Kholinne E, Zulkarnain RF, Sun YC, et al. The different role of each head of the triceps brachii muscle in elbow extension. Acta Orthopaedica et Traumatologica Turcica. 2018. ↩
References
- The different role of each head of the triceps brachii muscle in elbow extension. Acta Orthopaedica et Traumatologica Turcica (2018)Back to claim
- Human tendon adaptation in response to mechanical loading: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine - Open (2015)
Frequently Asked Questions
- Are skull crushers and overhead tricep extensions the same?
- Not quite. A tricep extension is a movement family. A skull crusher is usually a lying extension with the upper arm near vertical, while an overhead extension is done standing or seated with the upper arm beside or behind the head. They share the elbow movement and differ mainly in shoulder position, stability, and how heavy you can go.
- Is the overhead tricep extension better for the long head?
- The long head crosses the shoulder joint, so raising the arm overhead lengthens it more than a lying version does. That is the main reason lifters favour overhead work for it. Whether that produces measurably more growth than skull crushers is not settled by the source cited on this page, so treat it as a reasonable preference rather than a rule.
- Does a behind-the-head skull crusher count as overhead work?
- Partly. Lowering the weight behind the head, or lying on an incline bench, moves the upper arm back and lengthens the long head more than a classic skull crusher. A fully overhead cable or dumbbell extension still takes the shoulder through the most flexion.
- Should I do both in the same workout?
- You can, but they overlap, so the second one adds less than it seems to. If you pair them, load one heavy at lower reps and keep the other lighter, or alternate them across sessions.
- Which should I choose?
- Choose the version whose shoulder position, equipment, and range you can control. Heavier loading favours skull crushers, a deeper stretch and easy cable setup favour overhead extensions, and using one consistently for several weeks tells you more than switching.
- Which is easier on the elbows and shoulders?
- Neither is inherently safer. Skull crushers put more of the demand through the elbow when the load is heavy, while overhead extensions ask for more shoulder range. Pick the position that feels comfortable, reduce the load if it does not, and get individual assessment rather than pushing through sharp pain.
- Is an EZ bar better than a straight bar for skull crushers?
- Many lifters find the angled grip of an EZ bar more comfortable on the wrists. That is a comfort preference, not a proven injury-prevention effect, so use whichever bar lets you keep the elbows steady.